I-93

1.Field of application

The Central Artery of I-93 in Boston, Massachusetts.

2.Circumstances of repair

3.Types of structure

The bridge is a viaduct structure with bi-level rigid steel frame bents supporting the reinforced concrete decks, two longitudinal I-girder per level ,and multiple longitudinal stringers per level.

Plan view and framing plan is shown in figure 1,2. The columns of the bents are box sections and the transverse beams of the bent are either box section or I-section (Fig.3,4,5). The longitudinal girder top and bottom flanges (an webs) are coped by flame-cutting to permit a bolted web connection, using double angle, to the transverse beams of the bent. The girder webs are bolt connected to the double angles which are bolt connected to the transverse beams of the bent (Fig.6). The structural steel is ASTM A588.


File not found: "I-93_h69.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.1 Plan view of bents


File not found: "I-93_h70.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.2 Typical framing plan for one span.


File not found: "I-93_h71.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.3 Bent 7 elevation (with beam I-section).


File not found: "I-93_h72.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.4


File not found: "I-93_h73.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.5


File not found: "I-93_h74.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.6

4.Details of loading

Fluctuating loads due to vehicles live load. This resulted in significant cyclic stress occurred from the longitudinal traction and braking forces.

5.Description of damage

Ⅰ. Horizontal cracks were found along the longitudinal girder bottom web-flange weld at the flange termination (Fig.7).

Ⅱ. Vertical cracks were found in the longitudinal girder webs at the reentrant corner of the bottom cope and along the bolt fixity line of the connection angle (Fig.8).

The fatigue cracks occurred at locations where the girder web was bolted full depth to the connection angle.

Other locations where the girder web was not bolted full depth to the connection angles did not contain fatigue cracking in either the cope or the connection angles (Fig.9).

Ⅲ.A crack was found at the intersection of the fillet weld, which connected the closure plate to the column flange, and the groove weld, which connected the top flange of the box beam to the column flange.


Causes of fatigue crack were as follows:


Ⅰ.The lateral displacement of the longitudinal girder bottom flanges originated during fabrication (Fig.8) and the corresponding web gap distortion at the connection between the longitudinal girder and transverse beam.

Ⅱ.End fixity of the double angle connections resulted in large cyclic stresses acting on the web plate.

·Coping by flame-cutting which resulted in high tensile residual stress along the cut edge and a sharp.

Ⅲ.A fabricated lack of fusion plane at the corner fillet welds of the bent transverse beams.


File not found: "I-93_h75.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.7 Vertical and horizontal fatigue cracks at the bottom web cope.


File not found: "I-93_h76.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.8 Cross-section view of angle with fatigue cracks.


File not found: "I-93_h77.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.9 Longitudinal girder not bolted full depth to the connection angles.

6.Repair method applied

A further retrofit was required. Holes were drilled in the girder web and flange and an angle, 200 by 200 by 29mm, was bolted to the girder inside web and flange and to the connection angle (Fig.10,11,12). 16mm fill plate was used on the web and the lower bolt holes ware reamed for bolting.


File not found: "I-93_h78.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.10 1984 retrofit procedure for all of the longitudinal girder bottom web gaps.


File not found: "I-93_h79.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.11 1984 retrofit of a longitudinal girder bottom web gap viewed from girder interior.


File not found: "I-93_h80.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.12 1984 retrofit of a longitudinal girder bottom web gap viewed from girder exterior.

Both procedure needed to enable the flanges of the wide-flange to be bolted to the webs of the column (Fig.13,14).


File not found: "I-93_h81.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.13 1987 retrofit procedure for I-section of beam-column connection.

File not found: "I-93_h82.gif" at page "U.S.51 Br."[ź]

Fig.14 1987 retrofit of beam-column connection showing flange of wide-flange bolted to web column.


トップ   新規 一覧 単語検索 最終更新   ヘルプ   最終更新のRSS